Allstate vs State Farm Insurance: Which is Better?

Choosing the right insurance provider is a decision that can significantly impact your financial security and peace of mind. Among the myriad options, Allstate and State Farm stand out as two of the industry’s giants, each boasting a robust portfolio of insurance products and a long-standing history. This article aims to thoroughly compare these two insurance titans, dissecting their offerings, customer service, pricing, and more to help you make an informed decision.

Insurance Company Overview

Allstate Insurance

Founded in 1931, Allstate has become a staple in the American insurance market. Known for its comprehensive range of products, including auto, home, life, and renters insurance, Allstate prides itself on its personalized approach and innovative solutions. Financially, it’s a juggernaut, consistently earning high marks from rating agencies, a testament to its stability and reliability.

State Farm Insurance

State Farm’s roots date back to 1922, and it has since grown into a household name. Its wide array of services covers traditional insurance products and banking and investment services. Renowned for its extensive network of agents and commitment to customer relationships, State Farm holds a significant portion of the U.S. insurance market, reflecting its trustworthiness and customer loyalty.

Product Comparison

When it comes to product offerings, both Allstate and State Farm provide a similar range.

  • Auto Insurance: Both offer competitive auto insurance policies. Allstate is known for its unique programs like Drivewise, which rewards safe driving, while State Farm provides the Drive Safe & Save program, appealing to cost-conscious consumers.
  • Homeowners Insurance: Both companies offer comprehensive homeowners insurance. Allstate stands out with its innovative tools, like the Digital Locker app for inventory management, whereas State Farm is praised for its straightforward and extensive coverage options.
  • Life Insurance: In life insurance, the two differ slightly. Allstate is lauded for its various life insurance products, including term, whole, and universal life policies. While offering similar products, State Farm is often recognized for its customer-centric approach and agent accessibility.

Allstate and State Farm Insurance Customer Service and Satisfaction

The caliber of customer service is a critical differentiator between insurance providers.

Allstate: Allstate is renowned for its robust customer support network, offering 24/7 assistance. According to J.D. Power’s U.S. Auto Insurance Study, Allstate ranks above average in customer satisfaction, with particular commendation for its claim handling process and policy offerings.

State Farm: State Farm excels in personal agent interaction. Customers often praise the one-on-one attention and local knowledge of their agents. State Farm consistently ranks high in the same J.D. Power study, particularly in customer interaction and policy information clarity.

Allstate vs. State Farm Pricing and Value

Price is invariably a pivotal factor in choosing an insurer, but weighing it against the value provided is important.

Allstate: Allstate’s premiums are generally competitive but may be higher than some of its counterparts. However, they offer many discounts, including new car, multi-policy, and smart student discounts, which can significantly lower premiums.

State Farm: Known for its more affordable rates, State Farm is often the go-to for budget-conscious consumers. They offer a range of discounts, such as accident-free and defensive driving course discounts, that can further reduce costs.

Claims Process

The efficiency and ease of the claims process are crucial in times of stress.

Allstate: Allstate’s claim process is highly digitalized, featuring a mobile app that allows customers to file and track claims easily. Customers report satisfaction with the speed of claim resolution and the transparency of the process.

State Farm: State Farm also offers a streamlined claims process, 24/7 support and an easy-to-use online system. Their customers often cite the personal support received from agents during the claims process as a significant positive.

Technology and Accessibility

In today’s digital age, the technological offerings of an insurance company can greatly enhance customer experience.

Allstate: Allstate is at the forefront of digital innovation in insurance. Their user-friendly app facilitates claim filing and tracking and offers tools like Drivewise to monitor driving habits. Additionally, their website provides comprehensive resources for policy management and claims information.

State Farm: State Farm’s technology is centered around customer interaction. Their mobile app allows for easy policy management claim filing and even includes a feature to connect with agents directly. The State Farm website is also robust, offering a wide range of tools and resources for customers.

Financial Strength and Stability

An insurer’s financial stability indicates its ability to meet policyholder obligations.

Allstate: Allstate has consistently received high ratings from financial rating agencies like A.M. Best and Moody’s. These ratings reflect its strong financial health and ability to pay out claims, even during economic downturns.

State Farm: State Farm is financially robust, often receiving top ratings from A.M. Best and other rating agencies. Its long-standing market presence and large customer base contribute to its financial stability.

What do Customers Say About Allstate and State Farm Insurance?

Allstate Insurance

  1. Customer Reviews and Ratings (ConsumerAffairs):
    • Overall Rating: 3.4/5 (Based on 2,210 reviews)​​.
    • Key Pros: Coverage in all states, various discount programs, innovative technology​​.
    • Key Cons: Premium increases, limited availability of some services like Ride for Hire​​.
    • Featured Reviews: Mixed, with some customers praising the coverage and agent support​​​​, while others report issues with claims handling and premium increases​​.
  2. Customer Satisfaction (
    • Overall Satisfaction: 84% of customers were happy with Allstate’s customer service​​.
    • Ease of Service: Ranked high with 88% satisfaction​​.
    • Policy Offerings: 83% satisfaction, which is about average​​.
    • Recommendation: 86% of customers would recommend Allstate​​.
    • Trustworthiness: Scored high, alongside Travelers, behind State Farm​​.
    • Renewal: 90% of customers plan to renew with Allstate​​.
    • Claims Handling: Rated in the top third of all insurance companies​​.
    • Digital Experience: Received a score of 34%, one of the better scores in this area​​.

State Farm Insurance

  1. Customer Reviews and Ratings (ConsumerAffairs):
    • Overall Rating: 3.4/5 (Based on 3,823 reviews)​​.
    • Key Pros: Intuitive website and app, multi-policy discounts, numerous local agents​​.
    • Key Cons: It is not the cheapest option and requires personal information for quotes​​.
    • Featured Reviews: Varying experiences, with some praising the seamless claims process​​, while others express frustration over rate increases and policy cancellations​​​​​​.
  2. Customer Satisfaction (NerdWallet):
    • Overall Satisfaction: State Farm scored 80 out of 100, higher than the average among seven insurers​​.
    • J.D. Power Rating: Scored 878 out of 1,000 points for customer satisfaction, slightly above the industry average​​.
    • TrustPilot Score: Holds a score of 7.5 (Great) based on 67% positive customer reviews​​.
    • Financial Strength: Highest A++ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best​​.

Comparative Analysis

  • Customer Satisfaction: Both companies have similar overall customer satisfaction scores, with State Farm having a slight edge in the J.D. Power rating.
  • Claims Handling: Allstate is rated higher than State Farm, indicating stronger customer confidence in its claims service.
  • Digital Experience: Allstate has a better digital experience score, highlighting its strong online presence and app usability.
  • Trustworthiness and Renewal Intentions: Both companies are trusted by their customers and have high renewal intentions. However, State Farm leads slightly in trustworthiness.
  • Customer Reviews: The customer reviews for both companies show a mix of positive and negative experiences, with specific strengths and weaknesses noted for each. Allstate is praised for its ease of service and policy offerings, while State Farm is commended for its intuitive digital platforms and agent network.

In summary, Allstate and State Farm offer competitive insurance services with strengths in different areas. Customers’ choices may depend on individual preferences for digital experience, agent interaction, policy offerings, and price.

Frequently Asked Questions About Allstate vs State Farm Insurance

Q: How do Allstate and State Farm compare in terms of pricing for auto insurance?
A: Pricing varies based on individual factors like driving history and location, but State Farm generally offers more competitive rates than Allstate.

Q: What types of discounts do Allstate and State Farm offer for their insurance policies?
A: Both companies offer a range of discounts, including safe driver discounts, multi-policy discounts, and discounts for anti-theft vehicle devices.

Q: Are there any notable differences in the homeowners’ insurance policies between Allstate and State Farm?
A: Allstate is known for its customizable policies, while State Farm offers more standardized coverage but often at a lower cost.

Q: How user-friendly are the mobile apps of Allstate and State Farm for managing policies and filing claims?
A: Both Allstate and State Farm have highly rated mobile apps that allow easy policy management and claim filing, with State Farm’s app generally being more intuitive.

Q: Can I expect reliable roadside assistance from Allstate and State Farm?
A: Yes, both insurers offer robust roadside assistance programs, but Allstate’s program is known for more comprehensive coverage.

Q: How do Allstate and State Farm compare customer satisfaction?
A: State Farm generally has higher customer satisfaction ratings, especially in handling claims and customer service.

Q: What are the options for life insurance policies with Allstate and State Farm?
A: Both offer a variety of life insurance policies, including term, whole, and universal life insurance, but the specifics and pricing can vary.

Q: Is there a significant difference in the speed of processing claims between Allstate and State Farm?
A: State Farm is often praised for quicker claim processing times, but this can vary based on the complexity of the claim.

Q: Do Allstate and State Farm offer unique coverages or benefits that set them apart?
A: Allstate is known for its unique offerings like accident forgiveness and new car replacement, while State Farm offers a more straightforward, traditional insurance experience.

Q: How do the two companies handle rate increases after an accident or traffic violation?
A: Both companies may increase rates after an incident, but State Farm’s increases are typically less steep than Allstate’s.

Q: What are the options for bundling different insurance policies with Allstate and State Farm?
A: Both offer bundling options like auto-home or auto-life insurance policies, which can provide significant discounts.

Q: Are there any specific advantages for young or new drivers choosing Allstate or State Farm?
A: State Farm offers more competitive rates for young drivers and discounts for good students, while Allstate provides teen driver education resources and discounts.

Jennifer Wilkens

Jennifer has a degree in communications from Utah Valley University and enjoys writing business and financial news articles. She loves snowboarding and spending time with her two kids.

Recent Articles

Posted in